The Contractor Checklist: How to Spot Misclassification Before Your 1099s Go Out

Close-up of a 1099-MISC tax form label on a blue-toned background.

Every business that uses independent contractors makes a quiet bet: that the people it pays on a 1099 really are in business for themselves. Most of the time that’s true. When it isn’t, the bill can be steep: back overtime, unpaid payroll taxes, penalties, and sometimes legal fees on top.

With 1099 season approaching, now is the right time to check. Here is why classification matters, what’s changing at the federal level, and a practical checklist for reviewing every contractor on your books.

The label in your contract won’t protect you

Many business owners assume a signed independent contractor agreement settles the question. It doesn’t.

Regulators and courts look at the reality of the working relationship. The federal test is commonly called the “economic reality” test, and it asks a simple question: is this person in business for themselves, or economically dependent on you for work? The DOL’s proposed rule keeps this test and asks whether workers are in business for themselves or economically dependent on an employer. If the day-to-day facts look like employment, a contract calling someone a contractor won’t change the outcome.

The agency has also signaled that actual practice matters. One law firm analysis noted that the DOL’s emphasis on the parties’ “actual practice” could lead to future disputes if the working relationship is different from what the paperwork says. In other words, a clean agreement can still lose to messy reality.

The consequences of a wrong call can include:

  • Back overtime and minimum wage. Employees are generally entitled to overtime. Contractors aren’t.
  • Unpaid payroll taxes. That means employer-side Social Security and Medicare taxes, withholding, and unemployment insurance contributions.
  • Penalties and interest on top of what you owe.
  • Benefits exposure. Workers reclassified as employees may have claims to benefits, leave, and workers’ compensation coverage.
  • Claims from the worker. Many misclassification cases start when a contractor files for unemployment or a wage claim after the relationship ends.

What’s changing at the federal level

The rules have shifted often. A 2021 DOL rule gave way to a 2024 rule, and now a third version is on the way. On February 26, 2026, the DOL proposed a new rule that would revert to the 2021 framework and rescind the 2024 rule.

The big change is emphasis. The 2024 approach weighed all factors without favoring any one. The proposal would put greater weight on two core factors: control over the work and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss. If both core factors point the same way, the proposal says there is a substantial likelihood that is the worker’s accurate classification. Analysts expect that, if finalized, it would likely make it easier for employers to argue that workers are independent contractors.

That sounds like good news for businesses, and it may be. But three caveats matter before you relax:

  1. It’s a proposal. Public comments on the proposal were open through April 28, 2026. Check the DOL’s site or talk to counsel for the current status before you rely on it.
  2. Enforcement has already moved. In May 2025, the DOL said its Wage and Hour Division would no longer apply the 2024 rule’s analysis in FLSA investigations. The standards are in flux, which is exactly why documenting how each relationship works is worth the effort.
  3. Other agencies and states have their own tests. The IRS and your state labor and unemployment agencies don’t have to follow the DOL’s approach. Commentators note that even under a more employer-friendly federal rule, misclassification still carries substantial risks, and many states are passing their own laws on the question.

The takeaway: don’t wait for the federal rule to settle. A solid, fact-based review protects you under any version of the test.

The contractor checklist: five steps to run now

Step 1: List every contractor

Start with a complete inventory of everyone you pay on a 1099, including long-term ones. For each person, record:

  • What they do for you
  • When they started and how long they’ve worked for you
  • How much you pay them per year
  • Whether they have a written agreement, and when it was last updated

Long-term contractors deserve the closest look. A project-based freelancer who comes and goes looks very different from someone who has worked alongside your team for four years. The longer and more continuous the relationship, the more it resembles employment.

Many businesses are surprised by this step. Contractors added over time, by different managers, for different reasons, often never get reviewed as a group.

Step 2: Check who controls the work

Control is one of the two factors the DOL’s proposal emphasizes, and it’s usually the first thing an auditor examines. Ask for each worker:

  • Do you set their hours or require them to be available at certain times?
  • Do you dictate how the work is done, rather than just the result you want?
  • Do you require them to follow your procedures, scripts, or training?
  • Do you supervise their work, or evaluate them the way you would an employee? ● Can they turn down work or choose their own projects?

A contractor typically controls the way the work gets done. You define the outcome and they decide how to get there. If you’re directing methods and schedules, that’s a red flag.

Step 3: Look at the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss

This is the other core factor. A true contractor is running a business, with real chances to earn more through initiative or lose money through bad decisions. Ask:

  • Can they increase their earnings by working smarter, taking on more clients, or hiring help?
  • Do they invest in their own tools, equipment, software, or workspace?
  • Do they bear financial risk, such as unreimbursed expenses or the cost of fixing mistakes?
  • Do they market themselves and have other clients?

If someone is paid a fixed hourly rate, uses your equipment, and takes no financial risk, they look much more like an employee than an entrepreneur.

Step 4: Scan for the common red flags

Beyond the two core factors, these patterns tend to draw attention from regulators:

  • They work only for you. Exclusivity isn’t decisive on its own, but a worker with no other clients looks dependent. (Note that the proposed rule would not count exclusivity as part of the permanence factor, unlike the 2024 rule. Some states and agencies still care about it.)
  • They use your equipment, systems, or workspace.
  • They do the core work of your business. A delivery company’s drivers and a design agency’s designers are close to the heart of what those businesses do. The closer the work is to your central operations, the harder it is to defend contractor status.
  • They’re treated like staff. They have a company email address, appear on your org chart, attend staff meetings, or are introduced to customers as part of your team.
  • They’re paid like employees. That means regular amounts on a regular schedule, with no invoices or per-project pricing.
  • There’s no end date. An open-ended relationship with no defined project resembles a job.
  • Skill level and independence. Work requiring specialized skill that the person brought to you, rather than learned from you, supports contractor status.

No single red flag decides the question. What matters is the overall picture, so note every one that applies to each worker.

Step 5: Check your state’s rules

This step is the one most often skipped. Some states use a stricter test than the federal one. The best-known example is the “ABC test,” which presumes a worker is an employee unless you can prove all three of its prongs, typically including that the work is outside your usual course of business. Under that kind of test, a worker who passes the federal analysis can still fail the state one.

State unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation agencies also run their own audits, and they don’t always coordinate with federal regulators. If you operate in more than one state, check each one. Your state labor department’s website is a good place to start, and an employment attorney can confirm which test applies.

What to do if a worker looks like an employee

Finding a risky relationship during your review is a good outcome. It means you can fix it on your own terms. You generally have a few options:

  • Convert the worker to an employee. This is the cleanest fix when the relationship truly works like a job.
  • Restructure the relationship. If the worker really is a contractor on paper but your practices have drifted, change the practices. Let them set their own schedule, use their own tools, and take on other clients, then update the agreement to match what actually happens.
  • End the arrangement. Sometimes it makes sense to wind down a relationship that can’t be restructured.
  • Get legal advice before you act. Reclassification can have tax and back-pay implications, and there are IRS programs and state processes that may apply. An attorney or tax professional can guide the approach.

Timing matters. It’s far better to address a questionable relationship before the 1099s go out than after an audit or a claim has started the clock on penalties.

Whatever you decide, document it. Keep a short record for each contractor showing the facts you reviewed and why you reached your conclusion. If you’re ever questioned, that record shows good-faith diligence.

Make it a habit

Classification isn’t a one-time project. Relationships change, scope creeps, and a project-based freelancer slowly becomes a permanent fixture. Build a lightweight review into your routine:

  • Review all contractors once a year, ideally before 1099 season.
  • Re-check any contractor whose role, hours, or pay changes significantly.
  • Have managers get HR or finance sign-off before engaging a new contractor. ● Update agreements so they describe how the work actually happens.

If you’d rather have help, we’re happy to review your contractor list with you.

This post is general information, not legal or tax advice. Classification depends on the specific facts and on federal and state law, so talk to a qualified attorney or tax professional about your situation.

author avatar
Neil Katz