Quick Answer
For a 25-person company, fractional HR typically runs $6,000–$12,000 per year, a PEO roughly $24,000–$36,000 in admin fees, and a full-time HR manager about $185,000–$200,000 fully loaded, based on the BLS median salary of $140,030 plus benefits. Fractional HR usually costs the least; the best fit depends on what you need delivered.
The headline comparison: annual cost at 25 and 60 employees
Here are the three options side by side, priced annually for two common company sizes. Every figure below is unpacked line by line in the sections that follow, using BLS data, NAPEO research, and 2025–2026 industry pricing benchmarks.
| Model | Pricing basis | 25 employees (annual) | 60 employees (annual) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fractional HR retainer | $500–$1,000/mo (1–25 employees); $1,500–$3,500/mo (26–100) | ~$6,000–$12,000 | ~$18,000–$42,000 |
| PEO admin fees | $80–$120 per employee per month (most common flat range) | ~$24,000–$36,000 | ~$57,600–$86,400 |
| Full-time HR manager | BLS median salary $140,030 + benefits load | ~$185,000–$200,000 | ~$185,000–$200,000 |
The spread is stark: at 25 employees, a full-time manager costs roughly 15 to 30 times a fractional retainer. But these numbers buy very different things, so walk through the math before deciding. All three ranges are national benchmarks — local labor markets, industry risk, and multi-state complexity will move any of them — yet the relative gaps between the models hold remarkably steady.
What does a full-time HR manager really cost, line by line?
Far more than the salary. Per the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median HR manager earned $140,030 as of May 2024 — and that’s the midpoint, with experienced candidates in competitive markets commanding more.
Then comes the load. The BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation data (December 2025) shows benefits make up 29.9% of total private-industry compensation — insurance, retirement, paid leave, and legally required costs like employer payroll taxes. Apply a 30–40% benefits-and-overhead load to that median salary and the rough math lands at $185,000–$200,000 per year, all-in. Add recruiting the role itself (SHRM’s 2025 benchmarking puts average executive cost-per-hire at $35,879), equipment, and software seats, and year one climbs higher still.
One more line most spreadsheets miss: a single manager is one person. Vacation, resignation, or a skills gap in, say, multi-state leave law leaves you exposed at one point of failure — a real cost that never shows up as a number.
There’s an opportunity-cost line too. Recruiting an HR manager takes real time — SHRM’s 2026 recruiting benchmarks put median executive time-to-fill at 45 days — and the compliance gaps you’re hiring to fix keep accruing while the seat is empty. Rough math: if the search plus a notice period runs a full quarter, you’ve spent three exposed months before your first dollar of HR value arrives.
What does a PEO really cost, line by line?
PEOs price two ways, per 2026 pricing guides: a flat fee of $40–$160+ per employee per month, most commonly $80–$120, or 2–12% of total payroll, most commonly 3–7%.
The flat model is easy math: at $80–$120 PEPM, 25 employees costs $24,000–$36,000 a year and 60 employees runs $57,600–$86,400. That squares with independent research — NAPEO’s ROI white paper puts the average PEO cost at $1,395 per employee per year, or about $34,875 for a 25-person firm and $83,700 for 60.
The percentage model needs more care: a 60-person company with $4 million in payroll paying 3–7% would spend $120,000–$280,000 — rough math, and a reminder that percentage pricing scales with every raise you give. Two caveats cut the other way. First, admin fees don’t include benefits premiums; you still pay those, though a PEO’s group buying power can lower them. Second, the fee includes substantial administration — payroll processing, benefits administration, workers’ comp — and NAPEO’s research credits PEO clients with a 27.2% average ROI. You’re buying infrastructure through co-employment, not a senior HR leader.
What does fractional HR really cost, line by line?
Fractional HR is priced as a monthly retainer for an embedded senior HR leader. Industry pricing analyses (2025) put typical retainers at $500–$1,000 per month for 1–25 employees, $1,500–$3,500 for 26–100, and $3,000–$6,500 for 101–250.
So the annual math: a 25-person company pays roughly $6,000–$12,000; a 60-person company, $18,000–$42,000 depending on scope and cadence. Where you land inside the band depends on hours per month, how many states you operate in, and whether the engagement includes heavier lifts like a compliance audit or handbook rebuild in the early months.
Rough math for perspective: even at the top of the 26–100 band, $3,500 a month is $42,000 a year — about a fifth of the loaded cost of one median full-time manager. Inverted, the full-time hire has to deliver roughly five times the value of a senior fractional leader just to break even on price.
What’s notable is what the retainer buys per dollar: senior judgment. Under a service like Exceptional HR Solutions’ Fractional HR, the retainer covers strategic leadership plus hands-on execution — compliance, employee relations, hiring infrastructure — from credentialed professionals. For per-employee framing across every provider type, see the full outsourced HR cost per employee per month guide.
What does each price include — and not include?
The three numbers aren’t buying the same product, which is why comparing totals alone misleads.
- Full-time manager ($185K–$200K): includes daily on-site presence and total dedication. Does not include a bench — one person’s knowledge has edges — or coverage when they leave.
- PEO ($24K–$86K at these sizes): includes payroll processing, benefits administration, and access to large-group benefits pricing via co-employment. Does not include a senior strategist who coaches your managers, designs your org, or leads investigations — and benefits premiums remain your cost.
- Fractional HR ($6K–$42K at these sizes): includes senior HR leadership, compliance ownership, and employee-relations handling on a part-time cadence. Does not include full-time daily presence, and payroll processing may be a companion service — Exceptional HR Solutions, for instance, offers Payroll and Benefits Administration alongside the retainer.
The models can also stack: some companies keep a PEO for infrastructure and add a fractional leader for judgment, or use fractional HR now with a plan to hire in-house later. A provider offering several of these lines under one roof can also blend them, which changes the math again — usually in your favor, since bundled administration prices below the sum of separate vendors.
Cheapest isn’t the same as best fit
On pure dollars, fractional HR wins at almost any small-company size — but the right question is which gap you’re filling. If your pain is benefits buying power and payroll mechanics, the PEO math can justify itself. If you’re past 100–150 employees with daily employee-relations volume, the full-time hire starts to pencil. If what you lack is senior HR leadership without a $185,000 commitment, fractional is built for exactly that.
One more data point for the PEO column before you decide: NAPEO’s fact sheet research found PEO clients grow 7–9% faster and see 10–14% lower employee turnover than comparable firms — a reminder that the right model, not the cheapest one, is the thing that actually pays for itself.
How the three models differ structurally — co-employment versus embedded leadership versus project advice — is covered in fractional HR vs PEO vs HR consultant, and the deeper hire-or-retain decision gets a full treatment in fractional HR vs a full-time HR manager. Run your own numbers with those pages open, and the fit usually declares itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do PEO administrative fees include the cost of benefits premiums?
No. The $80–$120 per-employee monthly admin fee cited in 2026 pricing guides covers administration — payroll, benefits enrollment, workers' comp handling — not the insurance premiums themselves. Those you still pay, though PEOs can offer access to large-group rates. Always model admin fees plus projected premiums when comparing a PEO against other options.
What would a full-time HR generalist cost instead of a manager?
Per BLS May 2024 data, HR specialists earn a median of $72,910 — roughly $95,000 or more once you apply a typical benefits load. That's still several times most fractional retainers, and a single mid-level generalist can't match senior-level depth across compliance, compensation, and investigations, which is the trade many companies underestimate.
Why do some PEOs charge a percentage of payroll, and does it matter?
Percentage pricing — 2–12% of payroll, most commonly 3–7% per 2026 guides — is simpler for the PEO to administer, but your HR cost then rises automatically with every raise and bonus you pay. Flat per-employee fees keep the price tied to headcount instead. If you're comparing quotes, convert both to annual dollars at your actual payroll.
Can we combine a PEO with a fractional HR leader?
Yes, and it's a common stack: the PEO supplies payroll processing and benefits buying power, while a fractional leader supplies strategy, compliance judgment, manager coaching, and employee-relations handling — the things co-employment doesn't provide. Budget both, but note the fractional retainer often replaces consulting spend and owner hours you're already paying somewhere.
At what company size does the full-time HR hire start to win on value?
The math typically turns somewhere past 100–150 employees. SHRM benchmarking shows an average of 1.7 HR staff per 100 employees, so by then you genuinely need a full-time person's capacity, and daily presence starts earning its premium. Many companies bridge with fractional HR until then, and let their fractional leader help recruit the in-house hire.
Ready to talk through what the right HR support looks like for your business?
Not ready yet? Take our free HR Assessment or explore the Free Founder Resource Library.
